Spin coating defects: causes and fixes

Most spin coating defects trace back to a short list of causes: particles and bubbles, the way the liquid was dispensed, the speed profile, and the air around the substrate. Name the defect correctly and the fix is usually quick. The table below covers the ones we’re asked about most, and the notes after it explain the less obvious ones.

Defects at a glance

DefectWhat it looks likeLikely causeFix
CometsShort streaks with a spot at the head, pointing outwardA particle or bubble pushed outward by the spreading filmFilter the material, clean the substrate, let the resist degas, start the spin promptly
PinholesSmall holes through the filmParticles on the substrate or in the liquid, or tiny bubblesClean the substrate, filter, degas, check the dispense tip for damage
BubblesRound voids, often near the centreAir from shaking or pipetting, gas released by some positive resists, a cut or burred tipLet the bottle stand before use, dispense gently, replace damaged tips
StriationsFine radial lines running out from the centreSurface tension changes as solvent evaporates unevenlyKeep the bowl atmosphere solvent-rich, reduce exhaust, coat at a stable, slightly cooler temperature
Swirl patternA spiral of thickness variationStrong exhaust, off-centre dispense, high acceleration or a spin that’s too shortReduce exhaust and acceleration, centre the dispense, lengthen the cast step
Uncoated areasBare patches, usually at the edgeToo little liquid, slow acceleration or poor wettingDispense more, ramp faster, improve wetting with a spread step or adhesion promoter
Thick centre spotA thicker disc a centimetre or so acrossDelay between dispense and spin, so the centre starts to dry firstStart spinning straight after dispensing
Chuck markA faint circle the size of the chuckThe chuck changes the local temperature, so the film dries at a different rate above itUse a plastic (acetal) chuck, and let substrate and chuck reach room temperature
Edge beadA raised rim at the edgeLiquid gathers at the edge before it can fling offSolvent edge bead removal, or the recipe changes in our edge bead guide
Corner build-up and ripples on squaresThick corners and wavy patternsTurbulent airflow at the cornersRecessed chuck, lower speed, closed bowl (see our guide to coating squares)
Skins and clotsLumps or dried flakes in the filmResist drying at the tip of the dispense nozzle between runsDispense a little to waste first, keep idle times short, reduce exhaust near the nozzle
DewettingThe film pulls back into islands or leaves bare areas after spreadingLow surface energy, moisture or contamination on the substrateDehydration bake, vapour HMDS priming, or an adhesion layer on noble metals
Cotton candy fibresFine dried strings round the edge, in the bowl and on the lidMaterial at the edge dries into threads before it can leave as dropletsSlow the cast step, lower the exhaust during casting, run BSR or EBR early in the spin (see our cotton candy guide)
Poor run-to-run repeatabilityThickness drifts between runs or daysChanging exhaust or humidity, off-centre substrates, varying dispense volumeStable exhaust, closed bowl, centering device, automated dispense
Top-view sketches of six spin coating defects: comets, striations, swirl, chuck mark, edge bead and uncoated areas
Six common defects, seen from above.

Particles and bubbles

Comets, pinholes and most bubbles share a cause: something in the liquid or on the surface that the spreading film flows around. Three habits deal with most of them.

  • Filter at the point of use. A filter of 0.2 µm or finer removes most particles. Small bubbles below about 10 µm can’t be seen and rise very slowly, so they need time to clear.
  • Let the material settle. After shaking or decanting, give thin resists 20 minutes or more, and viscous ones a few hours. Positive resists can release gas when the bottle is first opened, so loosen the cap and leave them to settle.
  • Dispense gently. Keep the tip close to the surface and avoid pushing the last drop out of a pipette, which brings air with it.

Striations

Striations are fine radial ridges, spaced at around half the film thickness. As solvent evaporates, the surface cools and its composition changes, and the resulting differences in surface tension drive tiny circulating flows in the film. When the film sets, those flows leave ridges behind. Slowing evaporation is the cure. Keep the bowl closed, cut the exhaust during the cast step, and coat in a stable, slightly cooler room. With a stubborn material, a solvent blend that evaporates more evenly also helps.

Chuck marks

A faint circle matching the chuck size comes from heat. Metal chucks conduct heat into or out of the substrate, so the film above the chuck dries at a slightly different rate. Plastic chucks reduce the effect a great deal, which is why CEE make their standard vacuum chucks from acetal (Delrin). Letting substrates reach room temperature before coating helps as well.

Repeatability

When a film is good on one run and slightly off on the next, the cause is usually in the surroundings. Exhaust that varies with what else is running on the duct, humidity that rises through the day, hand-dispensed volumes and substrates loaded slightly off centre all add up. A closed bowl, programmable exhaust, automated dispense and a centering device take most of these variables out. Logging every run, as DataStream does on Apogee tools, makes it easy to see which one changed.

How SiSTEM can help

If a defect doesn’t match anything here, send us a photo and your recipe. We’ll look at it with CEE’s process team. Apogee spin coaters, spin chucks and dispense systems are all supplied and supported by SiSTEM across the UK and Europe.

More technical guides

All technical guides